The Opinion of " Property Less Means Personality Less" Be Humanism or Materialism?
- 法学院－已发表论文 
作为一种客观存在,人格与财产之间存在着复杂的双向互动关系:一方面,人格制约财产,财产对人格存在着依附关系;另一方面,财产状况又会反过来对主体的人格产生一般性影响。“无财产亦有人格”强调的是作为人之人格应然的理想图景,即人格的享有不应以财产的享有为前提。“无财产即无人格”试图讲述的则是实然的社会图景,即无财产的人不能享受到他应有的人格尊严。面对与理想图景不符的现实,以及由此产生改造之的良好愿望,不同的人选择了不同的进路。谁更对,谁更错?或许不是一张“某某主义”的标签就可以分得清的。As the fact,the relationship between personality and property is complicate and interactive: on the one hand,incoming of the subjective is restricted by his personality;on the other hand,the property condition of the subjective can commonly affect his personality.People who argues that "a person owns entire personality even he/she is property less" emphasizes on the ideal view of what a person's personality should be.And people who argues that "property less means personality less" emphasizes on the real view of society,which means that a person who owns none property can't enjoy his due personality.When confronting the fact that the reality does not be accord with the ideal view,people rising the will of improving the reality.To achieve this object,different people choose different ways.Who is right? Who is wrong? The answer is under question.